Resource Adequacy History
Repository of historical information and materials regarding resource adequacy.
History
|
Decisions & Resolutions |
Summary |
|
Adopting Local Capacity Obligations For 2027-2029, Flexible Capacity Obligations For 2027, And Program Refinements.
|
|
|
|
Decision on Track 3 of Resource Adequacy
|
|
|
Decision on Track 2 of Resource Adequacy
|
|
|
Decision on Track 1 of Resource Adequacy
|
|
Decision on Phase 3 of the Resource Adequacy Implementation Track
|
|
|
Decision on Phase 2 of the Resource Adequacy Reform Track This decision addresses issues scoped as Phase 2 of the Reform Track and adopts implementation details for the 24-hour slice-of-day framework, including adopting compliance tools, resource counting rules for various resource types, and a methodology to translate the Planning Reserve Margin to the slice-of-day framework
|
|
|
Decision Adopting Local Capacity Obligations for 2023 - 2025, Flexible Capacity Obligations for 2023, and Reform Track Framework
|
|
|
Decision On Phase 1 of the Implementation Track: Modifications to the Central Procurement Entity Structure
|
|
|
Decision on Track 3.B.2 Issues: Restructure of the Resource Adequacy Program This decision addresses issues scoped as Track 3.B.2, which were proposals to restructure the RA program, and multi-year flexible RA requirements. The restructure proposals include consideration of hourly capacity requirements, reliance on capacity with energy attributes, use limitations, and a forward energy requirement construct.
|
|
|
|
Decision Adopting Local Capacity Obligations for 2022-2024, Adopting Flexible Capacity Obligations for 2022, and Refinements to the Resource Adequacy Program This decision adopts local capacity requirements for 2021-2023 and flexible capacity requirements for 2021 applicable to Commission jurisdictional load-serving entities. This decision also adopts refinements to the Resource Adequacy program.
|
|
Decision on Track 3.A Issues: Local Capacity Requirement Reduction Compensation Mechanism and Competitive Neutrality Rules
|
|
|
Decision Adopting Local Capacity Obligations for 2021-2023, Adopting Flexible Capacity Obligations for 2021, and Refining the Resource Adequacy Program
|
|
|
Decision on the Central Procurement of the Resource Adequacy Program This decision adopts implementation details for the central procurement of multi-year local Resource Adequacy procurement to begin for the 2023 compliance year in the Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) and Southern California Edison (SCE) distribution service areas, including identifying PG&E and SCE as the central procurement entities for their respective distribution service areas and adopting a hybrid central procurement framework. The decision declines to adopt a central procurement framework for the San Diego Gas and Electric distribution service area at this time.
|
|
|
Requires Community Choice Aggregators to submit to a process that includes a timeline for submission of Implementation Plans; a requirement to “meet and confer” between the CCA and the incumbent utility that can be triggered by either the CCA or the utility; a registration packet including a CCA’s service agreement and bond; and a Commission authorized date to begin service. |
|
|
Modified the citation program adopted by Resolution No. E-4017. |
|
|
Approved a citation program for enforcing compliance with certain RA filing requirements. |
|
|
Adopts local capacity requirements for 2021-2023 and flexible capacity requirements for 2021 applicable to Commission jurisdictional load-serving entities. This decision also adopts refinements to the Resource Adequacy program. |
|
|
Adopts revisions to the Resource Adequacy import rules based on Energy Division's proposal, with modifications. The Commission will consider the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and Powerex Corp.'s proposal in a subsequent Resource Adequacy proceeding after further development through the CAISO's processes. |
|
|
Adopts implementation details for the central procurement of multi-year local Resource Adequacy procurement to begin for the 2023 compliance year in the Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) and Southern California Edison (SCE) distribution service areas, including identifying PG&E and SCE as the central procurement entities for their respective distribution service areas and adopting a hybrid central procurement framework. The decision declines to adopt a central procurement framework for the San Diego Gas and Electric distribution service area at this time. |
|
|
Adopts local capacity obligations for 2020-2022, adopts flexible capacity obligations for 2020, and makes refinements to the RA program. |
|
|
Adopts flexible capacity obligations for 2019. |
|
|
Adopts local capacity obligations for 2019 and makes refinements to the RA Program. |
|
|
Adopts local and flexible capacity obligations for 2018 and makes refinements to the RA program. |
|
|
Adopts local and flexible capacity obligations for 2017 and makes refinements to the RA program. |
|
|
Adopts local and flexible capacity obligations for 2016 and makes refinements to the RA program. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2015. This decision adopts an interim “flexible capacity” framework for 2015-2017 as anticipated by D.13-06-024. This decision also defines “flexible capacity need”, adopts Qualifying Capacity and Effective Flexible Capacity for energy storage and supply-side DR resources. There are other minor RA program refinements for 2015. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2014. This decision adopts an interim “flexible capacity” framework which will be likely needed for 2015-2017 due to plant closures and less-flexible capacity. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2013. This decision studies flexible capacity proposals with an intention to issue a decision by the end of 2012. This decision also modifies the RA program to adopt a different calculation for the coincidence adjustment factor. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2012. This decision adopts eight new RA program refinements. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2011. The Qualifying Capacity Methodology Manual is adopted to provide load-serving entities with clearer direction for procuring RA resources. The RA true-up mechanism is deferred. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2010, modified certain resource counting rules, and addressed technical implementation issues. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2009, modified certain resource counting rules, and approved modifications to the compliance reporting procedure. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2008 and addressed zonal transmission constraints by adopting a “Path 26 Counting Constraint.” |
|
|
In response to various petitions for modification, modified D.05-10-042 to (1) require that RA-qualified firm liquidated damages import contracts specify a delivery point at an interconnection with the CAISO control area or a CAISO scheduling point, (2) exempt certain import contracts from the requirement that RA resources be available to the CAISO in real time, and (3) make minor clarifying wording changes. |
|
|
Addressed certain RA policy issues to establish clearer expectations among market participants regarding how contracts for RA resources will count towards meeting LSEs’ procurement obligations. Adopted protocols for forced and scheduled outages and refined the definition of the essential elements of an RA capacity product that can be readily traded. |
|
|
Established local procurement obligations for 2007 based on a 2007 Local Capacity Requirements (LCR) study by the CAISO, and set the stage for establishing local procurement obligations in future years. Addressed local RA policy and implementation issues including LCR study methodology, allocation of LCRs to Commission-jurisdictional LSEs, aggregation of local areas for compliance purposes, the compliance filing process, coordination with the CAISO’s Reliability Must Run designations, market power, waivers, and penalties for non-compliance. |
|
|
In response to applications for rehearing, modified D.05-10-042 to emphasize that the RA program in place for 2006-2008 is transitional and to clarify that the MOO provision to be included in RA contracts is an independent, RA-based requirement that does not attempt to change or alter the current Federal Energy Regulatory Commission-imposed MOO. |
|
|
Removed a prohibition on reselling and re-trading import capacity rights. |
|
|
Ordered the implementation of “system” RA program beginning in June 2006 and stated intention to establish “local” RA procurement obligations beginning in 2007. Addressed several RA program implementation issues, including the nature of the RA obligation (monthly system peak), the role of the CEC in reviewing and adjusting LSE load forecasts, coordination of the RA program and CAISO operations, load forecasting and resource counting issues, standard RA contract elements, the phase-out of the ability to count non-unit specific contracts for RA showings, the “must-offer obligation” (MOO) of RA resources to be available to the CAISO, and penalties for an LSE’s failure to meet RA procurement obligations. |
|
|
Accelerated implementation of the 15% PRM requirement from January 2008 to June 2006. Provided definition and clarification regarding the RA policy framework. Key elements of the decision included load forecasting protocols, resource counting conventions, month-ahead compliance showings by LSEs in addition to year-ahead showings, and a policy that resources that qualify for RA compliance purposes should be obligated to bid into the CAISO’s day-ahead market if not scheduled by the LSE. |
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.25-10-003 |
Track 2
|
|
|
Track 1
|
||
|
Workshop on 2026 LOLE Inputs and Assumptions
|
||
|
Workshop on Track 1 Proposals (February 10 & 11, 2026)
|
|
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.23-10-011
|
Workshop on UCAP, Long Duration Energy Storage, and Solar & Wind Accreditation (November 3rd and 4th, 2025)
|
|
|
Workshop on Track 3 Proposals (February 12 & 13, 2025)
|
|
|
|
Workshop on Track 3 Revised LOLE Study and Price Mitigation Proposals (January 23, 2025)
|
||
|
Workshop on Track 2 Topics (July 25-26, 2024) and Office Hour on LOLE Study + PRM (August 2, 2024) in R.23-10-011
|
|
|
|
Track 3
|
||
|
Track 2 |
||
|
Workshop on Track 1 Topics (February 14 + 28, 2024) |
|
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.23-10-011 Slice of Day Implementation
|
2027 Compliance Year
|
|
|
Workshop on Slice of Day Implementation
|
|
|
|
Slice of Day Planning Reserve Margin Calibration Tool
|
||
|
Exceedance Analysis
|
|
|
|
Slice of Day Office Hours |
|
|
|
Workshop on Slice of Day Calibration Tool and Thermal Ambient Derates
|
||
|
Workshop on LSE Showing Tool |
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.21-10-002 |
RA Implementation Track 3
|
|
|
RA Reform Track 2
|
|
|
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 10 - October 6, 2022 Wrap Up |
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 9 - September 29, 2022 Test Year, Follow-up on Remaining Issues
|
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 8 - September 21, 2022 CPUC/CAISO Processes, Flexible RA Requirements |
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop Demand Response - September 16, 2022 Demand Response |
|
|
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 7 - September 14, 2022 Planning Reserve Margin Part 2
|
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 6 - August 31, 2022 Compliance Tools
|
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 5 - August 23, 2022 Resource Counting Recap and MCC Buckets |
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 4 - August 17, 2022 Planning Reserve Margin |
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 3 - August 10, 2022 Hybrid Resource Counting
|
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 2 - August 3, 2022 Workstream 1: Master Resource Database, LSE Compliance Showing Tools
|
||
|
RA Reform Track 2 Workshop 1 - July 27, 2022 Resource Counting: Exceedance for Wind and Solar |
||
|
Implementation Track Phase II |
|
|
|
Implementation Track Phase I |
|
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.19-11-009/R.21-10 |
RA Reform Track |
|
|
January 19, 2022 Track 3B2 “RA Reform” Workshop 8 – UCAP and Multi-year RA |
||
|
January 5, 2022 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop 8 - Hedging |
||
|
December 17, 2021 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop 7A - Energy Storage Counting |
||
|
December 15, 2021 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop 7 - Recap on Slice of Day |
||
|
December 1, 2021 Track 3B2 “RA Reform” Workshop 6 - Need Determination |
||
|
November 17, 2021 Track 3B2 “RA Reform” Workshop 5 – Need Determination |
||
|
November 3, 2021 Track 3B2 “RA Reform” Workshop 4 – Resource Counting |
||
|
October 20, 2021 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop 3 - Resource Counting |
||
|
October 6, 2021 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop 2 - Structural Elements |
||
|
September 22, 2021 Track 3B2 "RA Reform" Workshop |
||
|
February 25, 2021 Track 4 and 3.B.1 Workshop |
||
|
February 8-10, 2021 Track 3.B.2 Workshops |
||
|
January 8, 2021 Track 3.B.2 Forward Energy Requirements Workshop |
||
|
November 24, 2020 BTM Workshop |
||
|
November 23, 2020 Track 3.B Workshop - Day 2 |
||
|
November 18, 2020 Track 3.B Workshop - Day 1 |
Presentations: |
|
|
August 13, 2020 LCR Working Group |
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.17-09-020 |
November 1, 2019 Central Procurement Entity Workshop |
Presentations:
|
|
September 5-6, 2019 RA Working Groups |
Presentations:
|
|
|
March 12 and 13, 2019 - Track 3 Workshop |
Presentations:
|
|
|
March 4, 2019 - Energy Division Track 3 Proposals |
||
|
July 19, 2018 - Multi-year/Single Buyer Workshop |
|
|
|
July 12, 2018 - Energy Division Track 2 Proposals
|
||
|
February 16, 2018 - Energy Division Track 1 Staff Proposals |
|
|
|
February 22-23, 2018 - Phase 1 Proposal Workshop |
||
|
Multi-year Requirement/Centralized Local Capacity Procurement/RA Reform |
|
|
|
Options for Treatment of Late LCR/FCR Studies and Alignment of CPUC RA Hours and CAISO Availability Assessment Hours |
||
|
ELCC Enhancements |
||
|
Preferred RFOs |
||
|
Flexible RA |
||
|
CCA Load Migration |
|
|
|
Local Counting for Demand Response/Use Limited Resources |
|
|
|
System Load Forecast Variability |
||
|
November 7, 2017 - Working group on Weather Sensitive Demand Response, Behind-the-Meter Resources and Comments on the R.17-09-020 OIR |
|
|
|
October 23, 2017 - Working Group on Path 26, Dispatchability, and Seasonal Local Requirements |
|
|
Proceeding |
Description |
Resources |
|
R.14-10-010
|
February 14, 2017 - Phase 3 Proposals Workshop Day 2 |
|
|
February 7, 2017 - Phase 3 Proposals Workshop Day 1 |
Agenda Flexible Capacity Demand Response & Storage Implementation |
|
|
December 22, 2016 |
||
|
December 16, 2016 - Energy Division Staff Proposals |
||
|
November 9, 2016 - Workshop on Flexible Resource Adequacy |
||
|
November 8, 2016 - Workshop on ELCC Methodology |
||
|
October 27, 2016 - Workshop on Load Forecast Adjustment Methodology |
||
|
April 5, 2016 - Workshop on Flexible Resource Adequacy |
Presentations:
|
|
|
March 25, 2016 - Energy Division Revised RA Proposals |
||
|
March 24, 2016 - Load Forecast Adjustment Webinar |
||
|
February 18, 2016 - Workshop: |
Presentations: |
|
|
February 9, 2015 - Workshop: |
Party Presentations |
|
|
January 6, 2015: |
Energy Division releases Staff Proposal as part of the Resource Adequacy Proceeding - RA Program Refinements. |
Archive
Resource Adequacy Reports:
- 2023 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2022 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2021 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2020 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2019 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2018 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2017 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2016 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2015 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2013-2014 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2012 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2011 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2010 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2009 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2008 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2007 Resource Adequacy Report
- 2006 Resource Adequacy Report
Resource Adequacy Market Reports:
Other Reports: