Demand Response Workshops

December 14, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Draft Work Plan

• Recording
• Slides
• Study Plan

November 16, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Penalty Enforcement Mechanism and Other Issues

• Recording
• Slides

November 2, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Penalty Enforcement Mechanism and Other Issues

• Recording
• Slides
• DSA Examples Excel File

October 5, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Capacity Shortfall and Penalty Enforcement Mechanism:

• Recording
• Slides
• CEDMC Comments

September 21, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Capacity Shortfall

• Recording
• Slides

September 8, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Bid Normalized Load Impact / Capacity Shortfall Penalty

• Recording
• Slides
• Comments

August 24, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Bid Normalized Load Impact Party Proposals

• Recording
• Slides
• Comments
• DSA Proposal
• CEDMC Proposal

August 10, 2023: CPUC SSDR Qualifying Capacity Working Group Meeting Bid Normalized Load Impact

• Recording
• Slides
• Performance Metric Numerical Examples

August 8, 2023: Load Impact Protocols Simplification Workshop

• Recording
• Energy Division Slides
• OhmConnect Slides
• SDG&E Slides
• Enersponse Slides

July 27, 2023: Incentive-Based Supply-Side Demand Response Qualifying Capacity Working Group Kick-off Meeting

• Agenda
• Slides

May 10, 2023: Demand Response Providers' and SCE Local Capacity Requirement Contracts Workshop on LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2024

• Agenda
• Recording of Morning Session
• Enersponse, Inc. Slides
• CPower Energy Slides
• Leapfrog Power, Inc. Slides
• OhmConnect, Inc. Slides
• Voltus, Inc. Slides
• Sunrun, Inc. Slides
• SCE Local Capacity Requirement (LCR) Contracts Slides

May 1-2, 2023: IOUs Workshop on 2023 LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2024

• Agenda
• Recording Day 1
• Recording Day 2
• PG&E Smart AC Slides
• SDG&E AC Saver Day Ahead (Thermostats) Slides
• SDG&E AC Saver Day of (Devices) Slides
• SCE Summer Discount Programs Slides
• IOU Base Interruptible Program Slides 
• IOU Capacity Bidding Program Slides
• SCE Smart Energy Program Slides

July 7, 2022: Demand Response Auction Mechanism (DRAM) Evaluation Workshop

• Agenda
• Slides
• Recording

May 18, 2022: Demand Response Providers and SCE Local Capacity Requirement Contracts Workshop on LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2023

• Agenda
• Morning Recording
• Afternoon Recording
• Enersponse Slides
• Leap Slides
• Nexus Renewables Slides
• OhmConnect Slides
• SCE Local Capacity Requirement Contract Slides
• Sunrun Slides
• Voltus Slides

May 3-4, 2022: IOUs Workshop on 2022 LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2023

• Agenda
• Recording Day 1
• Recording Day 2
• PG&E Smart AC Slides
• SDG&E AC Saver Day Ahead (Thermostats) Slides
• SDG&E AC Saver Day of (Devices) Slides
• SCE Summer Discount Program Slides
• IOU Base Interruptible Program Slides
• IOU Capacity Bidding Program Slides
• SCE Smart Energy Program Slides

May 25, 2021: Advanced DER & Demand Flexibility Management Workshop

• Click here for more information
  

May 3, 2021: DRPs Workshop on LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2022

• Agenda
• Slides

April 29 and 30th, 2021: IOUs Workshop on 2021 LIP Final Reports for Compliance Year 2022

• Agenda
• Slides

November 24, 2020: Behind-the-Meter Resource Adequacy Capacity Value Workshop

• Audiovisual Recording

May 2, 2020:  Demand Response Load Impact Protocols (LIPs) Annual Workshop (2 of 2) - Utilities' 2020 Final Reports

• Agenda
• PG&E Air Conditioning (AC) Cycling
• PG&E Critical Peak Pricing ("SmartRate")
• SCE Peak Time Rebate ("Smart Energy Program")
• SCE Default Time of Use (TOU)
• SDG&E Electric Vehicle Time of Use (EV TOU)
• SDG&E Default Time of Use Pilot

 May 1, 2020:  Demand Response Load Impact Protocols (LIPs) Annual Workshopt (1of 2) - Utilities' 2020 Final Reports

• Agenda
• Introduction to Load Impact Protocols (LIPs)
• Statewide Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)
• Statewide Base Interruptible Program (BIP)
• Statewide Capacity Bidding Program (CBP)

 December 5, 2019:  Demand Response Prohibited Resources 2019 Test Year Pilot Results

• Agenda
• Presentation on Pilot Results
• Utilities' Prohibited Resources in Demand Response - 2019 Test Year Pilot Results

 April 26, 2019:  Demand Response Measurement and Evaluation Committee (DRMEC)

• Agenda
• Introduction to DRMEC and Workshop
• Statewide Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)
• Statewide Base Interruptible Program (BIP)
• PG&E Air Conditioner Cycling (AC Cycling) ("SmartAC")
• Statewide Capacity Bidding Program (CBP)
• SCE Peak Time Rebate (PTR) ("Smart Energy Program") - Residential Thermostats
• SDG&E AC Cycling ("AC Saver DA") - Residential Thermostats

 February 11-12, 2019:  Demand Response Auction Mechanism (DRAM) Improvements Workshop

• Stakeholders developed proposals that were submitted on February 6, 2019
• Ruling issued February 28, 2019 summarizing the workshop, publishing party proposals, and asking questions for response by March 29, 2019 in A.17-01-012 et. al. 

January 16, 2019:  Demand Response Auction Mechanism (DRAM) Evaluation Workshop  

• Energy Division Public Report Presentation and Proposal Summaries (January 16, 2019)
• Ruling (January 4, 2019) & Final Public Report (interactive with complete attachments)  
• One-Page Proposals for Improvements Sunrun, CESA, Leapfrog, CEDMC, CLECA, Stem, Joint DR Parties, Olivine, PG&E, OhmConnect, and SCE (January 11, 2019)   

July 26, 2018:  Demand Response Auction Mechanism (DRAM) Evaluation Workshop

• Agenda, Energy Division Presentation, and ALJ Questions (July 26, 2018). 
• Informal comments from Parties and Stakeholders on the Interim Report: CLECA, OhmConnect, Olivine, SCE/PG&E, and SDG&E. (August 15, 2018).
• Additional information: August 6 Ruling on DRAM, Docket A.17-01-012 et. al., Research Plan    

June 27, 2018:  Utility Bill Credit Proposal to End Cost Recovery 

• Agenda
• Joint Utilities' Proposal on Competitive Neutrality Cost Causation Principles (filed February 2017) 
• Joint Utilities Proposed Approach to Determine Cost Refunds to Eligible CCA and DA Customers (filed January 30, 2018)  
• SDG&E Presentation
• SCE Presentation
  • SCE Supporting Narrative  
• PG&E Presentation
  • PG&E Supporting Narrative (in response to Energy Division data request)   
• Revised Utility Disenrollment and Cost Credit Letter for CCA and ESP Customers

 May 4, 2018:  Demand Response Measurement and Evaluation Committee (DRMEC) Load Impact Workshop

• Agenda
• Introduction to Load Impact Protocols
• Statewide Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)
• Statewide Capacity Bidding Program (CBP) and Aggregator Managed Portfolio (AMP)
• Statewide Base Interruptible Program (BIP)
• PG&E AC Cycling (SmartAC)
• SCE Summer Discount Plan (SDP)
• PG&E SmartRate
• SCE Peak Time Rebate (PTR) - Residential Thermostats
• SDG&E Peak Time Rebate (PTR) - Residential Thermostats

  February 15, 2018:  Demand Response Pilots for Disadvantaged Communities

• Draft Straw Proposal
• Appendix A:  List of Counties and Cities
• Two-page Summary  
• Agenda
• PowerPoints
  • CPUC  
  • CAISO
  • PG&E
  • SCE
• Informal Comments (zip file) - March 5, 2018

 February 14, 2018:  Managing Megawatts (MWs) under the Existing Reliability Cap

• Agenda  
• Proposals
  • CLECA
  • EnerNOC Inc. and CPower Energy Management Services
  • Joint IOUs

 June 26, 2017:  Limited Integration of Demand Response and Energy Efficiency Workshop

• Agenda
• Energy Division Staff Proposal
• Powerpoints
  • IOU Integration Efforts
  • LBNL  
  • Residential
  • Non-Residential

 May 16, 2017:  DR Prohibited Resources Implementation issues Workshop

• Agenda
• Staff Presentation  
• Meeting notes

 May 8, 2017: Demand Response Measurement and Evaluation Committe (DRMEC) Load Impact Workshop

• Agenda
• Overview of Randomized Control Trials
• AC Cycling Program
• Summer Saver Program
• Summer Discount Plan (SDP)
• Individual Regression and Table Generators
• Capacity Bidding Program (CBP) and Aggregator Managed Portfolio (AMP)
• Matched Control Group
• SmartRate
• Commercial Thermostats
• Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)
• Base Interruptible Program (BIP)

 March 1, 2017: DRAM Evaluation Plan & Metrics Workshops

• Agenda  
• Presentation  
• DRAM Evaluation Plan 

February 22, 2017:  Demand Response Program Review Workshop:  A Review of DR Programs in 2016 and Issues/Trends in 2017

• Agenda
  • Panel 1 Presentations:
    • EnerNOC
    • EnergyHub
    • PG&E  
    • SCE
    • SDG&E
  • Panel 2 Presentations:
    • PG&E, SCE, SDG&E, CAISO and Olivine  

 August - November 2016:  Click-Through Authorization, Direct Participation Enrollment Working Group Meetings

•  2016 Working Group Notes:  From July 25, August 24, September 13, October 18
•  October 12, 2016:  Informal Status Report
•  October 18 & November 3, 2016:  Energy Division Guidance 

 May 10-11, 2016: Demand Response Measurement and Evaluation Committee (DRMEC) Load Impact Workshop

• Agenda:
  • Welcome / Introduction
  • Randomized Control Trial Overview
  • PG&E SmartAC
  • SDG&E Summer Saver
  • SCE Summer Discount Plan
  • SDG&E Locational Pilot - TBP 
  • Matched Control Group Methodology Overview
  • PG&E Residential Smart Rate
  • SDG&E Commercial Thermostats
  • Individual Regression Overview & Statewide CBP and AMP 
  • Statewide BIP
  • SCE PTR
  • SDG&E PTR
  • Statewide CPP
  • SCE Electric Vehicle pilot (part 1)
  • SCE Electric Vehicle pilot (part 2)